
There are flowers that a man sends to a woman because he wishes to be loved. There are flowers he sends because he has been forgiven, and flowers because he has not. There are flowers for birthdays, for anniversaries, for wounded pride, for reconciliation and for those small domestic offences that are sometimes easier to acknowledge with roses than with words. And then there are flowers that are sent when the woman is dead, when the marriage has long been dissolved, when no answer will ever arrive, and when the only person who might have understood the gesture lies beyond the reach of every human apology.
For twenty years, fresh red roses were delivered to the resting place of Marilyn Monroe in Los Angeles. They were ordered by Joe DiMaggio, the great New York Yankees baseball player, the man she had married in January 1954 and divorced before the year was out.
A marriage that could not survive a single year had left behind a ritual that endured for two decades.
There is something in that extraordinary contrast which no novelist could improve by adding another tragedy, another kiss, or another beautifully constructed sentence. It belongs to that uncommon category of human stories in which the bare facts, patiently considered, possess more emotional power than invention.
Marilyn had been dead since 5 August 1962. She was thirty-six, an age at which ordinary women are still negotiating the meaning of their lives, still imagining houses they may inhabit, children they may raise, journeys they may undertake and old age they may eventually share with someone who knows how they take their morning tea.
But Marilyn Monroe was never permitted the luxury of being ordinary.
She had become the most recognisable woman in Hollywood, perhaps in the world. Her face belonged to cinema posters, magazine covers, bedroom walls and the excited imagination of men who knew absolutely nothing about her. She was desired by millions and understood by comparatively few. The blonde hair, the wonderfully expressive mouth, the soft voice and the seductive innocence had become a public enterprise.
Behind that magnificent commercial invention lived Norma Jeane, a woman acquainted with childhood instability, loneliness, painful insecurity and an enormous hunger to be taken seriously.
And into this complicated life came Joe DiMaggio.
He was already an American legend when they met in 1952. The baseball diamond had made him famous, disciplined him and given him the kind of masculine authority that America once conferred upon its sporting heroes. He was handsome in a stern, unembellished way, a man whose reserve was as much a part of his character as Marilyn's radiance was of hers.
The attraction was immediate enough to astonish their admirers. The woman every man imagined possessing had apparently fallen for a man who seemed almost indifferent to Hollywood's glittering absurdities. The baseball hero, who had spent his life mastering the speed of a ball, found himself confronting a woman whose emotional movements were altogether more difficult to anticipate.
They married on 14 January 1954 at San Francisco City Hall. Marilyn wore a modest dark suit with a white fur collar, and Joe stood beside her in the solemn dignity of a man who believed marriage might provide a private shelter from an excessively public world.
One can look at their wedding photographs today and feel the peculiar sadness of knowing what the smiling faces could not yet know. She leans towards him, luminous and delighted. He appears pleased, protective and faintly overwhelmed by the spectacle of the woman beside him.
There is tenderness in the photographs, and there is innocence. Even the most sophisticated lovers are occasionally innocent at the beginning.
But marriage is not preserved in wedding photographs.
The trouble was that Joe DiMaggio and Marilyn Monroe belonged to two different understandings of love. He valued privacy, domestic order and the respectability of a wife whose beauty might belong, at least in its more intimate expressions, to their marriage. She was an actress whose beauty was her livelihood, whose public image had been constructed by an industry and whose ambition extended far beyond being the celebrated wife of a celebrated man.
His jealousy became increasingly difficult. Her fame demanded the very public attention he disliked. The famous episode surrounding the filming of The Seven Year Itch, when Marilyn's white dress billowed above a New York subway grating before an excited crowd, came to symbolise the conflict between them.

For the watching world, it was an unforgettable image of cinematic seduction. For DiMaggio, it was reportedly a deeply upsetting spectacle. Their marriage deteriorated amid arguments, possessiveness and accounts of disturbing behaviour that cannot responsibly be brushed aside in the name of romance.
This matters because history is sometimes tempted to beautify a troubled relationship merely because the surviving photographs are beautiful.
Love does not become noble simply because it is intense. Jealousy is not necessarily devotion, and a man's inability to accept a woman's independence is not proof that he cannot live without her. The marriage was painful, and Marilyn's decision to leave it deserves the same respect as Joe's later gestures of affection.
She sought a divorce in October 1954. The public watched another great Hollywood romance collapse, as the public invariably does, with curiosity generously disguised as sympathy.
And yet, the story did not end there.
Time has a peculiar way of rearranging the emotional furniture of former marriages. The anger that once filled an entire room may shrink into an uncomfortable memory. Pride becomes less impressive. A person remembers not only why love failed, but why it had once seemed worth risking everything.
Marilyn married the playwright Arthur Miller in 1956. That marriage, too, eventually ended. Her professional career moved between remarkable achievement and exhausting difficulty, while her personal life remained exposed to the appetite of a public that consumed her unhappiness almost as enthusiastically as it consumed her beauty.
DiMaggio, meanwhile, never married again.
In the final years of her life, he and Marilyn renewed a friendship. He was again present in her circle, and there were reports of a possible reconciliation, although the certainty sometimes attached to those stories exceeds what the evidence can establish.
What can be said is that their relationship had not disappeared into the bitterness of their divorce.
Then came that dreadful August morning in 1962.
Marilyn Monroe was found dead at her home in Brentwood. The world received the news as an almost unbelievable interruption in its worship of beauty. Newspapers printed the familiar photographs, broadcasters repeated her name, and strangers who had never stood in her presence spoke as though they had lost someone intimately their own.
But Joe DiMaggio had known the woman behind the photographs.
He arranged her funeral. It was a small ceremony at Westwood Village Memorial Park, far removed from the grand public pageant that her fame might otherwise have encouraged. Much of Hollywood's powerful establishment was excluded.
There was something fiercely private in that final act. Perhaps it expressed anger, perhaps protectiveness, perhaps an old husband's desire to rescue something of the real woman from the crowds that had pursued her throughout her life. We cannot know precisely what passed through his mind.
We know only that he assumed responsibility for her farewell.
And afterwards, the roses began.
They arrived at the pink marble crypt with a regularity that must have made the gesture part of the cemetery's ordinary life. A florist received an order. Roses were selected, arranged and delivered. The flowers were fresh; the woman for whom they were intended had long since gone.
The deliveries continued for twenty years. Accounts differ on whether they arrived twice or three times a week throughout that period. Contemporary reporting in September 1982 recorded that the longstanding arrangement had been discontinued, after attracting growing public attention.
Consider the quiet magnitude of that ritual.
A flower is among the most perishable things that human affection employs. It begins to die almost as soon as it is cut. Its fragrance diminishes, its petals loosen, its colour fades. A rose possesses none of the durability of marble, bronze or engraved stone. Yet perhaps that was precisely what made the gesture so moving.

The flowers had to be replaced because flowers do not last.
Every delivery acknowledged that another few days had passed. Another season had turned. Another Christmas, another birthday, another anniversary had entered history without Marilyn. The world had changed, presidents had come and gone, Hollywood had discovered new beauties, and the girl in the white dress had become a permanent image from an increasingly distant age.
But the roses still arrived.
There is a profound Indian tenderness in the emotional meaning of such a practice. Across our country, flowers accompany worship, marriage, gratitude, farewell and remembrance. A garland placed upon a photograph is not an attempt to recover the dead. It is the living person's refusal to let remembrance become entirely abstract.
We cannot speak to those who have gone. We cannot undo the thoughtless sentence, the unnecessary quarrel or the occasion upon which pride conquered kindness. But we can return to their memory with something beautiful in our hands.
Perhaps that is all DiMaggio was doing.
Perhaps he was apologising. Perhaps he was preserving what had been good. Perhaps the flowers were neither apology nor declaration, but simply an expression of fidelity to a memory he had no wish to surrender.
No one has the right to turn an unknown private motive into an established historical fact.
It is tempting to describe DiMaggio as the one man who truly loved Marilyn Monroe. That would be a wonderfully marketable sentence, and perhaps a deeply unfair one. Other people loved her in ways that history has not recorded. Others failed her, and he failed her too. Love is not a competition won by whoever survives longest or sends the greatest number of flowers.
The more valuable truth is that their story contains both the tenderness of devotion and the consequences of human imperfection.
The roses cannot retrospectively repair their unhappy marriage. They cannot erase jealousy, restore Marilyn's peace or provide her with the ordinary happiness that so often eluded her. But neither must those failures make the gesture meaningless.
Human beings are rarely consistent enough to be either saints or villains in every chapter of their lives. They are capable of hurting the people they love, of recognising too late the tenderness they withheld, and of carrying the memory of an unfinished relationship for the remainder of their years.
Joe DiMaggio lived until 1999. Marilyn had been dead for nearly thirty-seven years.
By then, her fame had passed into a strange immortality. Young women born long after her death imitated her face; photographers recreated her poses; filmmakers searched for her melancholy beneath her glamour. The world had turned her into a legend that could never grow old.
DiMaggio, in contrast, had grown old in the ordinary human way.
And perhaps that is the final sorrow of this extraordinary romance: one of them remained eternally thirty-six, while the other was obliged to discover what it meant to continue living.
We are accustomed to imagining that the greatest love stories end with lovers united. Literature has taught us to admire the kiss that overcomes the quarrel, the reunion at the railway station, the arrival of the beloved before the last possible moment.
Life is generally less accommodating.
Some relationships end before love has entirely departed. Some people are better at remembering affection than sustaining it. Some discover tenderness only after pride has exhausted itself, when there is no longer anyone waiting to hear the confession.
And some send roses.
Not for a week, not for the usual period of mourning, but across the long, indifferent passage of twenty years.
Marilyn Monroe's resting place remains a destination for admirers. The flowers ordered by DiMaggio ceased in 1982, but the story of their arrival has survived the man who sent them, the woman who inspired them and the Hollywood generation to which they belonged.
There is no need to call it the greatest romance of the twentieth century. It was too troubled for such a comfortable distinction, and too human to deserve the false perfection of a fairy tale.
It was something sadder, stranger and perhaps more enduring: the story of a man and a woman who could not make a marriage last, but whose unfinished affection remained alive in a gesture of extraordinary persistence.
In the end, what makes the roses unforgettable is not that they conquered death. Nothing conquers death.
It is that, for twenty years, someone continued to remember.
And once, twice, sometimes three times a week, a little beauty was delivered to a place where beauty could no longer answer.