The Continental News   /   World Cinema   /   19 November 2026

A Hundred Immortals, One Crown: Marilyn Monroe Rules Hollywood as Variety’s Greatest Stars List Sets the World Arguing

From Monroe’s irresistible melancholy to Bogart’s battered masculinity, Chaplin’s genius and Shah Rukh Khan’s astonishing global kingdom, an audacious ranking raises an uncomfortable question: who decides whose dreams mattered most?

There was a time when Hollywood did not merely manufacture films. It manufactured gods, dressed them in silk, illuminated their faces with an almost religious tenderness, and sent them into the darkness of picture houses to persuade millions that life, however miserable, might yet contain a little splendour.

Some of those gods aged disgracefully, some died tragically, some discovered that fame was an expensive form of loneliness, and a precious few escaped the mortality that ordinarily governs human reputation. Their faces remained young while their audiences grew old. Their kisses survived marriages, their smiles survived wars, and their voices continued murmuring from cinema screens long after the bodies that produced them had returned to dust.

Now Variety has attempted the deliciously impossible: to arrange one hundred such immortals in order of greatness. Marilyn Monroe sits upon the throne. Humphrey Bogart stands immediately behind her, his face wearing that magnificent expression of a man who has already been disappointed by the world and intends to have another whisky regardless. Charlie Chaplin follows, the little tramp whose comedy made an international language of poverty and whose sorrow could arrive disguised as a joke.

Jack Nicholson and Katharine Hepburn complete the top five. Sidney Poitier, Marlon Brando, Tom Cruise, Toshiro Mifune and Barbra Streisand round out the first ten. Shah Rukh Khan comes in at number ninety-two; Henry Fonda closes the list at one hundred. It is not a scientific verdict, nor a tribunal of cinematic history. It is a critical judgement that invites disagreement.

A list of this magnitude is not merely a celebration. It is an argument, a provocation, and, inevitably, an exhibition of the prejudices by which each generation interprets the past. And what a beautiful argument it promises to be.

Marilyn Monroe: The Woman Who Became Larger Than Hollywood

Marilyn Monroe, 1953 publicity portrait
Marilyn Monroe, Hollywood’s enduring icon · Image: Wikimedia Commons; check licence and attribution

To place Monroe first is to acknowledge that movie stardom is not identical with acting proficiency. She was a gifted comic performer, particularly in Some Like It Hot, but her supremacy rests upon something considerably more mysterious. She became a universal image of desire, vulnerability and the unbearable loneliness of being adored by strangers.

Beneath the platinum hair and practised smile lived a woman whose intelligence was frequently underestimated and whose longing for serious artistic recognition remained painfully evident. Hollywood loved her body, marketed her innocence, scrutinised her private life and converted her distress into public entertainment. Her death in 1962, aged thirty-six, completed the terrible architecture of the legend. Time could never make her ordinary.

In the centenary year of her birth, Monroe’s first-place ranking feels fitting, even if it invites disagreement. Yet it also presents a philosophical difficulty. Are we honouring the woman who made the films, or the extraordinary mythology that developed around her after death? The two have become almost impossible to separate.

Bogart, Chaplin and the Masculinity Hollywood Has Forgotten

Humphrey Bogart and Ingrid Bergman in Casablanca
Bogart and Bergman in Casablanca · Image: Wikimedia Commons; check licence and attribution

Bogart, placed second, possessed none of the conventional perfection that Hollywood’s beauty merchants might have prescribed. His face was weathered, his manner sardonic, his romantic appeal inseparable from a suggestion of emotional damage. Yet in Casablanca, he made renunciation more seductive than conquest. He gave the cinema a form of masculine dignity that did not require a man to advertise his strength.

Charlie Chaplin in The Kid
Chaplin in The Kid · Image: Wikimedia Commons; check licence and attribution

Chaplin, at number three, achieved something even more remarkable. He made a character intelligible to audiences across continents without depending upon a shared spoken language. His tramp, with his ridiculous walk and magnificent dignity, represented the little man enduring the humiliations imposed by the powerful. Bogart specialised in disillusionment; Chaplin translated suffering into humour. Both understood that the most memorable performances often arise when a star reveals the weakness beneath the pose.

Brando, Nicholson, Cruise: Three Different Kinds of Power

Marlon Brando’s seventh-place position recalls the revolution he brought to American screen acting. His physical presence, emotional unpredictability and astonishing capacity to communicate inward conflict challenged an older theatrical tradition. In A Streetcar Named Desire and On the Waterfront, the human body appeared to think, desire and suffer almost independently of dialogue.

Jack Nicholson, at number four, made rebellion mischievous, dangerous and occasionally monstrous. His grin became a warning against assuming that civilisation had successfully domesticated human madness.

Tom Cruise, eighth, represents another achievement entirely. He has sustained the old-fashioned institution of the movie star through an era when franchises, digital effects and intellectual property increasingly compete with performers for the public’s devotion. His greatness is not necessarily measured by emotional range alone. It is also measured by the remarkable persistence with which he persuades spectators that the person at the centre of the spectacle matters as much as the spectacle itself.

The inclusion of Japanese master Toshiro Mifune at number nine is particularly welcome. His electrifying partnership with Akira Kurosawa supplied world cinema with performances of ferocity, humour and almost supernatural physical intensity. Yet one must still ask why so few non-Western actors occupy the upper reaches of a list claiming to encompass the entire world.

Shah Rukh Khan: Ninety-Second in Hollywood’s Imagination, a Giant Elsewhere

Shah Rukh Khan in 2023
Shah Rukh Khan, pictured in 2023 · Image: Wikimedia Commons; check licence and attribution

For Indian readers, the most conspicuous provocation is Shah Rukh Khan at number ninety-two. Here is a performer whose romantic gestures entered the emotional vocabulary of generations, whose films travelled across South Asia, the Gulf, Africa and diaspora communities, and whose public appeal has endured across changing political, cultural and cinematic landscapes.

From Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge and Devdas to My Name Is Khan and Jawan, he has repeatedly reinvented his screen persona without surrendering its essential magnetism. To rank him ninety-second is not necessarily to insult him; it is a critic’s judgement. But it does expose a fundamental problem with any worldwide hierarchy: whose audience is doing the counting?

A cinema-goer in Mumbai, Dubai, London or Lagos may carry an entirely different cultural map from an American critic. A star who has shaped the romantic imagination of hundreds of millions cannot be adequately understood through the degree of recognition he commands in Hollywood. Khan’s inclusion is significant. His modest placement is equally revealing. It should provoke a serious discussion about the geography of prestige rather than a tiresome contest of national vanity.

Henry Fonda at Number 100: When Rankings Become Absurd

And then there is Henry Fonda, occupying the final place. The man who gave American cinema Tom Joad, Juror Eight and some of its finest portraits of moral courage finds himself behind performers whose legacies are still being written. The placement illustrates the fundamental instability of such comparisons.

Zendaya, ranked ninety-eighth, has already demonstrated considerable talent and cultural influence. Timothée Chalamet, at eighty-sixth, belongs to an exciting generation. But comparing careers still unfolding with Fonda’s immense completed body of work is rather like judging an unfinished novel against a classic that has survived generations of readers.

There are other questions. What accounts for Robert De Niro standing at fifty-fourth, or Daniel Day-Lewis at sixty-eighth? And where are the Indian cinematic institutions represented by Amitabh Bachchan, Dilip Kumar or Rajinikanth? The absence of such names does not automatically invalidate the exercise, but it makes the word greatest difficult to defend without carefully explaining the criteria.

The Crown, the Camera and the Cruelty of Immortality

Ultimately, the list is valuable precisely because it cannot settle the argument it has begun. A star is not simply a great actor. Nor is a great actor necessarily a star. Stardom is that strange, almost alchemical relationship in which an audience begins to feel that a stranger belongs to its private emotional history.

Katharine Hepburn gave women an image of magnificent independence. Sidney Poitier carried an extraordinary historical significance into American popular cinema. Audrey Hepburn transformed elegance into a language. Elizabeth Taylor made glamour almost imperial. Each commanded a different kind of devotion. No numerical arrangement can adequately accommodate those distinctions.

Marilyn Monroe may wear Variety’s crown today, and few could deny the formidable power of her legend. But the cinema is not a kingdom in which one sovereign must diminish every other. Its true aristocracy belongs to those who have entered the memories of people they never met, comforted the lonely, challenged the comfortable and made strangers weep in the dark.

A hundred names have been written upon a list. A hundred arguments will follow. But beyond the mathematics of celebrity lies the more enduring truth: the greatest stars are not necessarily those who stood highest in the rankings. They are those whose light remained visible after the projector was switched off.

The Continental News · Read Beyond the Headlines

Share this story